Are You Sure That’s the Problem?

picture of several Rubik cubes

“The formulation of a problem is often more essential than its solution." – Albert Einstein and Leopold Infeld

A student performance issue emerges. Faculty engagement declines. An important initiative misses another milestone. Enrollment falls short of expectations. Leaders are expected to respond. We gather information, discuss what happened, identify the problem, and start working on a solution.

What if the problem we are solving isn’t actually the problem?

Sometimes what first gets our attention is a symptom. Other times, we quickly develop an explanation for what we see. Once that explanation feels right, it can shape the questions we ask, the evidence we notice, and the solutions we consider. The danger isn’t simply making a bad decision. We can make a perfectly reasonable decision for a problem we haven’t adequately understood.

Key Idea: Leaders can act decisively and still solve the wrong problem. What first appears to be the problem may be a symptom, an interpretation, or only one part of a more complicated situation. Effective leadership requires us to examine how we have framed the problem before committing significant effort to solving it.

Here are three ways to improve how we define the problem before deciding what to do about it.

1. Separate: What Are We Actually Seeing?

Key Idea: What happened is not necessarily the same thing as the problem. Consider the difference between these statements: A) student performance declined. B) Students aren’t adequately prepared. The first describes something we can observe. The second begins to explain why it happened. That distinction matters.

Leaders rarely encounter problems that arrive neatly defined. We encounter disappointing results, complaints, missed targets, recurring conflicts, or behaviors that concern us. We then make sense of what we see. Often, that interpretation becomes the problem before we realize we have made the transition. The issue isn’t that we interpret the information. We have to. The issue is becoming so comfortable with our interpretation that we stop recognizing it as one.

Try This: Take one problem currently demanding your attention and describe what you are seeing without explaining why it is happening. Ask:

  • What do we actually know?

  • What can we observe?

  • What have we already decided those observations mean?

See whether you can state the situation in one sentence without using causal language.

Example:
Student performance in a therapeutics sequence has declined significantly. That is what we know. Students aren’t studying enough. Students entered the program less prepared. The curriculum isn’t working. Those may eventually prove important. But each moves beyond the observation and begins framing the problem.

Before solving anything, separate what you are seeing from what you believe it means.

2. Challenge: What Else Could Explain It?

Key Idea: The first plausible explanation can narrow what we notice next. We understand this instinctively in clinical practice. Once a diagnosis seems to fit, it can become easier to interpret what comes next through that diagnosis rather than continue considering reasonable alternatives. Leadership judgment can face a similar challenge.

Experience makes this especially interesting. Experienced leaders recognize patterns. We have seen enrollment challenges, faculty conflicts, struggling students, delayed initiatives, and organizational resistance before. That experience helps us make sense of complicated situations quickly.

Experience helps leaders recognize patterns. Wisdom requires knowing when the pattern may be misleading you.

Try This: Once you have an explanation that seems reasonable, resist moving immediately to the solution. Ask:

  • What else could explain what we are seeing?

  • What evidence supports our current explanation?

  • What evidence doesn’t fit it?

  • Whose perspective might change how we understand the situation?

  • What would we notice if our initial explanation were wrong?

Then ask yourself:

What have I already decided the problem is, and what might I see differently if I questioned that assumption?

Example:
Return to the students struggling in the therapeutics sequence. The initial explanation is that students are entering the course less prepared. That makes remediation, additional study resources, or greater academic monitoring reasonable solutions. But the faculty look more closely.

Performance has declined most on assessments requiring students to integrate concepts across courses. The curriculum was recently reorganized. Faculty begin noticing that some prerequisite concepts are now introduced later than when students are expected to apply them. The original explanation may still be part of the picture but it no longer explains everything we are seeing. Curricular sequencing may also be part of the problem.

3. Define: What Problem is Actually Worth Solving?

Key Idea: Better problem framing changes the solution space. If we define the problem as inadequate student preparation, we might increase remediation, add study resources, or strengthen academic monitoring. If we define it as a curricular sequencing problem, we might examine prerequisites, course integration, sequencing, or assessment alignment. Neither frame should be accepted simply because it produces a convenient solution.

The point is to develop a problem definition that reflects what we understand well enough to guide responsible action. That doesn’t require perfect information. It requires enough disciplined inquiry to avoid becoming prematurely certain.

Try This: Before You Solve It, Reframe It

Choose one problem currently demanding significant attention or resources and work through five questions:

  • What are we seeing? Describe the observable condition without explaining it.

  • What have we decided it means? State your current explanation.

  • What else could explain it? Identify at least two credible alternatives.

  • What doesn’t fit our current explanation? Look deliberatively for evidence.

  • What problem is actually worth solving? Rewrite the problem based on what you now understand.

Then ask: What would we need to learn before committing significant effort to a solution?

Example:
Return to the student performance concern. If leaders define the problem as inadequate student preparation, the response may be more remediation, study resources, or academic monitoring. If further inquiry suggests that curricular sequencing is contributing to the performance issue, the problem changes. Leaders may need to examine course integration, sequencing, or assessment alignment. The same performance data remain. What changes is the problem leaders have decided is worth solving and, therefore, the actions available to them.

Final Thoughts:

Leaders are expected to solve problems. That expectation can create pressure to move quickly from concern to explanation to action. Sometimes speed is necessary. Sometimes our first explanation is exactly right. The discipline is making sure it has earned that confidence.

Better problem framing doesn’t mean studying an issue indefinitely or waiting until uncertainty disappears. It means slowing down just enough to distinguish what we know from what we assume, consider what else might explain what we are seeing, and determine whether the problem we have named is actually the one worth solving.

The hardest problem to reframe may be the one we are already convinced we understand. Before moving to the solution, ask yourself the question, “Are you sure that’s the problem?”

Next Steps to Strengthen Leadership Judgment

Complex organizational challenges rarely arrive with the problem clearly defined. EduLead-Rx works with academic pharmacy leaders to make sense of organizational challenges, strengthen leadership judgment, and translate insight into meaningful action and value.

For more information, email me at info@eduleadrx.com or schedule time to talk at edulead.as.me

#AcademicPharmacy #PharmacyLeadership #EduLeadRx #LeadershipDevelopment #StrategicLeadership #OrganizationalEffectiveness

Previous
Previous

Recalibration Is Not Retreat

Next
Next

What’s Really Getting in the Way?