“The origin of thinking is some perplexity, confusion, or doubt.” – John Dewey
The strategic priority is clear. The leadership team has agreed on a plan, resources have been committed, and people are working to make it happen. Then the evidence begins to tell a different story.
The results aren’t what you expected. Participation is increasing, but the intended outcomes aren’t improving. A process that looked promising during planning isn’t working quite as anticipated.
The leadership team faces a choice. Do we stay the course, give the plan more time, or change something? That decision can be harder than it sounds. Leaders invest considerable effort in creating strategies, building consensus, and securing resources. Once we have publicly committed to a direction, changing the approach can feel like admitting we got something wrong.
Recalibration isn’t a retreat from the strategy. Sometimes it is exactly what responsible execution requires.
Key Idea: Effective leaders distinguish between commitment to an important outcome and attachment to the original plan for achieving it. When new evidence challenges our assumptions or reveals that an approach isn’t working as expected, recalibration can protect the strategic intent while improving the path forward.
Here are three ways to recognize when an adjustment is needed and lead it with confidence.
1. Protect: What Are We Really Committed To?
Key Idea: Commitment to an outcome is different from commitment to the original approach.
When leaders develop a plan, we make decisions based on what we know at the time. We identify problems, select initiatives, assign responsibilities, and establish expectations for progress. Those decisions matter. They create direction and help people coordinate their efforts.
The original approach is still a set of choices made under particular assumptions and conditions. As implementation unfolds, we learn things we couldn’t have known during planning. The challenge is recognizing which commitments should remain stable and which decisions need to change.
Sometimes leaders become so invested in the original plan that changing an activity, timeline, or method begins to feel like abandoning the goal itself. Those are not the same thing.
Try This: Choose an important initiative and ask:
What outcome are we ultimately trying to achieve?
Which elements of our current approach are essential to that outcome?
Which activities, timelines, or methods could change without compromising our purpose?
Separate the commitment from the method. The distinction can create more room for responsible adjustment than we initially recognize.
Example:
A college launches a student-success initiative to improve progression and retention. The plan includes expanded academic support, faculty referrals, and additional student resources. After two semesters, participation in support services is increasing but progression has not improved as expected. The commitment to student success remains important. Increasing participation was a means to that end, not the end itself.
The leadership question is no longer simply whether the initiative is being implemented. It is whether the current approach is producing the improvement the college intended.
2. Examine: What Is the Evidence Telling Us?
Key Idea: Persistence is valuable when it serves the intended outcome. It becomes a problem when we continue an approach primarily because we have already invested in it.
Most leaders recognize the importance of persistence. Meaningful organizational change takes time, and early results are not always encouraging. We shouldn’t abandon an initiative simply because implementation becomes difficult. But there is another risk.
Once we have invested time, resources, and personal credibility in a decision, it can become harder to reconsider that decision objectively. We may explain away disappointing results, emphasize encouraging activity measures, or assume the approach simply needs more time.
This is one reason recalibration requires more than analytical judgment. It also requires an honest examination of our own attachment to the original decision.
Am I protecting the outcome we committed to or the approach I originally chose?
That question can be uncomfortable, particularly when we were the person who advocated for the initiative.
Try This: When progress isn’t matching expectations, examine the evidence before deciding whether to persist or adjust. Ask:
What did we expect to see by now?
What are we actually seeing?
What assumptions appear to be holding, and which need reconsideration?
What evidence would justify continuing our current approach?
What evidence would justify changing it?
The goal isn’t to find a reason to abandon the plan. It is to make sure our decision to continue is as deliberate as our decision to change.
Example:
The student-success initiative appears active and well supported. More students are using resources, faculty are making referrals, and the college has invested in additional services. Yet progression outcomes remain largely unchanged.
A closer examination reveals that many students experiencing academic difficulty are not identified until after major assessments. By the time referrals occur, the opportunity for early intervention may have passed. The support itself may be valuable. The problem may be when and how students are connected to it.
Continuing the initiative without examining that distinction could produce more activity without meaningfully improving student outcomes.
3. Adjust: What Needs to Change, and How Will We Lead It?
Key Idea: Recalibration becomes credible when leaders make a deliberate adjustment, explain the reasoning, and connect the change to the outcome everyone is working to achieve.
Recognizing the need to change is one challenge. Leading the change is another. When leaders adjust a plan without explaining why, people may interpret the decision as inconsistency, or a loss of confidence in the original strategy. That doesn’t mean leaders should avoid changing direction. It means they need to communicate what they have learned and how that learning informs the next decision.
People should understand what remains constant, what is changing, and why the adjustment makes sense.
Try This: The Recalibration Check
Choose one initiative where the evidence suggests an adjustment may be warranted. Work through four questions:
PROTECT: What strategic outcome or commitment must remain unchanged?
EXAMINE: What have we learned that challenges our original approach?
ADJUST: What specific activity, resource, timeline, responsibility, or method should change?
COMMUNICATE: How will we explain what remains constant, what is changing, and why?
Then determine what evidence you will watch to assess whether the adjustment is helping. The purpose isn’t to redesign the entire initiative. Sometimes a targeted change is enough to improve progress.
Example:
Rather than expanding the same activities, the college decides to shift part of its effort toward identifying students at risk earlier in the semester.
The leadership team explains the commitment to improving student progression has not changed. What has changed is the college’s understanding of when support may be most effective and how students should be connected to it.
The college will now examine whether earlier identification and intervention are associated with improved student outcomes. The strategy remains focused on student success. The approach has been recalibrated based on what the college learned.
Final Thoughts:
Leaders often receive recognition for persistence, determination, and staying the course. Those qualities matter. Meaningful progress rarely comes without obstacles, and not every disappointing result requires a change in direction.
Sometimes a sound approach needs more time, better execution, or greater consistency. But persistence shouldn’t become an excuse to ignore what we are learning.
Recalibration isn’t changing direction whenever the work becomes difficult. It is changing the approach when the evidence gives us a good reason to do so. That may require revisiting assumptions, redirecting resources, or explaining a difficult decision to people who were invested in the original plan. It requires a willingness to separate our personal commitment to a decision from our responsibility for the outcome.
Strong leaders remain committed to the outcome without becoming captive to the original plan. As you consider one of your current priorities, ask yourself: Am I staying the course because the evidence supports it or because changing the approach feels like retreat?
Next Steps to Effectively Recalibrate Your Approach
Effective leadership requires knowing when to stay the course and when to adjust. EduLead-Rx works with academic pharmacy leaders to strengthen strategic judgment, navigate organizational challenges, and translate leadership insight into meaningful action and value.
#AcademicPharmacy #PharmacyLeadership #EduLeadRx #LeadershipDevelopment #StrategicLeadership #OrganizationalEffectiveness